Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-10811146-20150516204009/@comment-14250-20190325153142

I don't want to give up so easily. Sometimes people have more than 2 parents. We can work with this. Perhaps some are godparents, or they are adopted by a different couple after the disappearance of the 1st pair?

Operating under a "it's all one continuity" approach, we should have a list of things which complicate the theory (different sets of parents being one such thing, any references to IRL events decades apart without character aging possibly being another) and see if we can find plausible possible explanations which could account for them.

If push comes to shove, we can blame things on Castiel or Vincent Van Ghoul.